What Over the Counter Hair Products Work Best?

female hair patient

I’m often asked by my patients who suffer from hair loss what over the counter hair products are most beneficial. What shampoo should I use? What about hair conditioners? Am I brushing my hair too much or too little? Is it safe to color my hair?

Hair Growth Basics

We are born with approximately 100,000 hairs on our scalp. Unlike many other cells, we do not create nor regenerate hair cells throughout our lifetime. In order to notice clinical baldness it is necessary to lose approximately 50% of the hair follicles in a specific area of the scalp, such as the frontal area or crown. Hair grows approximately 1.25 centimeter or ½ inch each month, and the growth cycle of an individual hair follicle varies from 2-7 years. The growth phase is called anagen. About 85-90% of hairs are in the anagen phase at any given time.

The catagen phase represents that time when the hair naturally sheds from the scalp and involves about 1% of hairs on our scalp. This phase lasts about two weeks. This is seen naturally as we shed about 100 hairs daily during shampooing and hair brushing.

The telogen phase is characterized by the hair follicle remaining in a resting state which varies from 1 to 4 months in duration. At any given time, approximately 10-15% of the hairs on our head are in this phase of the hair cycle.

It is very important to understand hair growth so that patients are not alarmed when they notice a daily loss of hairs from the scalp. The loss of hair is unaffected by showering, shampooing, the use of conditioners, and hair brushing. Coloring of the hair does not appreciably affect hair loss. However, coloring and perming your hair at the same time may be damaging to the hair shaft. Separate these two treatments by about two weeks to be safe. It is best to perm your hair initially, wait at least two weeks, and then color your hair. Some vitamin supplements like Nutrafol have been specially designed for patients suffering from hair loss. Topical agents and supplements have little to no scientific evidence of clinical effectiveness.

Rogaine

Rogaine is the only over the counter product which has scientific evidence demonstrating hair growth. Rogaine works by prolonging the growth of the hair cycle and increasing blood flow to the scalp. I advise both men and women to use the 5% product, which is the more concentrated formula and marketed towards men. You will not see an immediate response but continuous use should be part of your daily routine. Some people describe increased irritation or dryness with the 5% formula which is usually temporary. If it continues, I recommend the milder concentration marketed towards women.

Light Therapy

There is recent evidence to suggest that low level light therapy may also be effective at stabilizing hair loss. While the exact mechanism is unknown, researchers believe the benefits are due to stimulation of increased blood flow to the scalp. There are no side effects to such treatments, and light therapy can be added to your daily hair loss regimen. Many products are available online, and I often recommend a laser cap designed by Capillus which many of my patients have found to be beneficial.

Takeaway

Hair loss is distressing for both men and women. However, it is important to understand the natural hair cycle so that you do not become unduly concerned by the natural shedding of hair from the scalp. If you are concerned about significant hair loss, then make sure to see a physician who has special expertise and experience in the management of hair loss including non-surgical and surgical options.

About Dr. Richard Chaffoo

Board-Certified Plastic Surgeon · California Hair MD

Board certification
  • American Board of Plastic Surgery (verify)
  • American Board of Facial Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery (verify)
  • American Board of Otolaryngology – Head and Neck Surgery (verify)
Education and training
  • Nine years of postgraduate surgical training after medical school
  • Two surgical residencies in plastic and reconstructive surgery and otolaryngology/head and neck surgery
  • Three fellowships: Facial Aesthetic Surgery at Stanford University Medical Center, Head & Neck Oncologic Surgery at Stanford University Medical Center, Burn Surgery at UCSD Medical Center
  • Fellowship, Facial Aesthetic Surgery, Stanford University Medical Center
  • Fellowship, Burn Surgery, UCSD Medical Center
  • MD, Wake Forest University, Bowman-Gray School of Medicine (1975–1979)
  • Internship, Surgery, Naval Regional Medical Center, Portsmouth, VA (1979–1980)
  • Residency, Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery, Naval Regional Medical Center, Portsmouth, VA (1980–1984)
  • Residency, Plastic Reconstructive and Hand Surgery, Oregon Health and Sciences University (1999–2001)
  • Fellowship, Facial Plastic Surgery, Stanford University Medical Center (1986–1987)
  • Fellowship, Head and Neck Oncologic Surgery, Stanford University Medical Center (1986–1987)
  • Fellowship, Burn Surgery, San Diego County Regional Burn Center, USCD Medical Center (1998–1999)
Hospital affiliations
  • Scripps Memorial Hospital, Encinitas – Former Chief of Plastic Surgery
  • Scripps Memorial Hospitals, Encinitas (former Chief of Plastic Surgery)
  • U.S. Naval Hospital, Groton, Conn
  • U.S. Naval Hospital, San Diego, CA (1987–1990)
Memberships
  • American Society for Aesthetic Plastic Surgery – Member
  • American Society of Plastic Surgeons – Member
  • San Diego Plastic Surgery Society – Past President
  • Fellow, American Academy of Otolaryngology, Head and Neck Surgery
  • Fellow, American College of Surgeons
  • Fellow, American Head and Neck Surgery Society
  • Fellow, American Academy of Facial Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery
  • Member, California Society of Plastic Surgeons
Awards
  • Top Plastic Surgeon by Castle Connolly
  • Top Hair Restoration Surgeon, Aesthetic Everything (2016)
  • Top 10 Leading Facial Plastic Surgeon in the West, Aesthetic Everything (2015)
  • Best resident presentation, Northwest Society of Plastic Surgeons annual meeting, Kaui, Hawaii
NPI
1639271505
Offices
La Jolla · Beverly Hills · San Diego · Newport Beach · Corona Del Mar

Read Dr. Richard Chaffoo's full bio

  • Share: